April 23, 2008

Weird Things Happening in (and outside of) Brookline

1 garden gnome Weird Things Happening in (and outside of) Brookline

The blogosphere got all hot and bothered with two big Brookline stories last week:

  1. The foreclosure on the elegant Longwood Towers.
  2. The rebuilding of Brookline — just outside of Charlotte, North Carolina, that is.

In case you hadn’t heard, about 200 units at Longwood Towers will be auctioned off as a single block next month. New York-based iStar Financial announced plans to bid on the condos and, with any luck, complete renovations on the towers, where units range from $300,000 to $1.5 million.

Will prices precipitously drop? Will the poor souls who bought-in find themselves out of a whole lot of bucks? And what about the valet parking?

Although I don’t have any answers, I disagree with some of my blogging colleagues (I’m talking to you John Keith!) who wrote off the whole project as a “lemming” –you know, a follower.

Greg Kiely at the Brookline Real Estate Blog mentioned poor location for the Longwood project. Call me crazy, but but I think it’s in a perfect location. It’s a short walk to the Longwood Medical Area and directly across from the Longwood D branch Green Line station. It’s steps away from the Emerald Necklace and within walking distance of Coolidge Corner and the Fenway. Remember, not everyone wants to live on Boylston Street!

Prices for these units don’t seem that far off target; keep in mind, in 2007, the average house in Brookline sold for $1.4 million and the average condo fold for half a mil. Someone will pay to live in a lovely 20′s era building with green space and views. Certainly, other million-dollar condos exist in the neighborhood. So what’s the problem?

John and Greg speculated buyers dislike the awkward floor plans and high condo fees. I can see how fees might hurt sales a bit, but plenty of empty-nesters looking for something near the city without ending up downtown might show some interest. Maybe things would pick up with lower fees and updated floor plans.

We’ll closely watch what happens next, but I wouldn’t write off Longwood Towers, yet. And for those who already bought in the building– chin-up!

The second story, of replicating Brookline in North Carolina, is so laughable it’s hardly worth a mention. Evidently, a developer so loved the look of Brookline, Massachusetts, he thought he’d recreate it outside Charlotte, North Carolina. I’m with the Boston Globe real estate blogger Binyamin Appelbaum on this one. What makes Brookline special is its mix of single-family and multi-family housing built amidst ample greenery, yet still close to the big city. A gated community in the middle of nowhere isn’t Brookline; it’s Disneyland.

Image: freedigitalphoto.net


  • Pam
    True, although I guess at some point in all our lives, living next to 7 emergency rooms and a CVS becomes a big plus!
  • Pam,

    Don't get me wrong, I totally agree that it's a killer location, just NOT for what they were trying to create there. If you priced and developed space that worked for the young professionals who work in the medical area you would have an amazing property that would be the biggest success out there. My argument is that the luxury empty-nesters want to be a little closer to something other than 7 Emergency Rooms and a CVS.
  • Pam
    Anthony, I'm with you. I think LT has huge potential... I'm surprised we're the only ones who seem to think so!
  • Mark my words Longwood Towers will turn out to be an ownership gem in the city of Brookline. It just needs to be re-packaged and brought to market properly with the right unit mix, layouts and amenities...the location could not get any better for a project like this. Its a home run priced right and presented properly!
  • Pam
    That's a great point and probably explains a lot! Brookline has appeal for a certain set of singles and empty-nesters, but only at prices that are obviously less than what you would pay downtown. Maybe the prices at Longwood Towers were just too high to lure these buyers. Or maybe they should expand the size of the units so they could work as family apartments!
  • bikes2work
    I don't know if this clarifies or muddies the issue, but for me one of the main attractions to Brookline is the quality schools. Were it not for my young daughter, we would stay in downtown Boston or Cambridge. So if "good schools" is what's keeping Brookline prices elevated, then perhaps a condo high-rise that appeals to empty-nesters doesn't fit the mold.
blog comments powered by Disqus
close