The Bailout: Surprising, Frightening, Infuriating
I was surprised yesterday morning to hear that the House had rejected the $700 billion bailout package. Surprised, because I thought its passage was a sure thing. And surprised at my own reaction to it.
Part of me was happy it hadn’t passed, because the whole thing has smelled fishy from the start. Frankly, I’m not fully understanding what’s going on, and I’m not convinced that a $700 infusion from the government is going to help. And I’m confused: If Republicans favor less government and less regulation, why is the administration so eager for this bill to pass?
Part of me is scared, as I watch my IRA’s value plummet day after day and worry whether my husband and I will lose our jobs.
And part of me is angry — at the irresponsible and reckless behavior that got us into a mess I have no control over.
Apparently I’m not alone — look at the results of this MSNBC poll asking Americans what the next step should be. About 47% of respondents want the rescue plan renegotiated and passed immediately, and about 37% say we should let the chips fall where they may. (The rest want a brand-new solution.)
Tonight, I flipped on MSNBC and watched Rachel Maddow interview Laura Tyson, an Obama financial adviser, who gave the most cogent explanation I’ve heard yet about what’s going on. She said the word “bailout” is a mischaracterization; rather, the country is “in the midst of a massive credit contraction” that is “strangling the economy” and making it impossible for anyone to borrow money for businesses, student loans, or consumer purchases. This, she said, will lead to lost revenue, jobs, income and production, and the stock-market losses are reactions to the anticipated economic paralysis.
That makes sense. Tyson says she thinks that the reason the bill didn’t pass is because people don’t fully understand what’s going on, and she said that’s the fault of our leaders. One of the major duties of a leader, she said, is educating constituents.
I’m sure it will take a long, long time before any of us are fully educated as to what caused this crisis. In the meantime, we’re at the mercy of the financial markets and our government, neither of which has served us well, or earned our trust. Most Americans believe it’s their fault we’re in this predicament to begin with.
I can only hope that this fiasco is a wake-up call to everyone who overborrowed, overspent, and took too many chances with their/our money. But I don’t think it will, because most Americans are uneducated not only about the country’s finances, but also their own.
Recent Redfin posts:
Another Slam for Homeowners
The Irvine Market Report: Detached Home Stats, September 2008
Tustin: The Tale of Two Brooks
Max D. said:
Those of us who have been watching the housing market for the past few years saw something like this coming. The market run-up was unsustainable. Yet it was a huge surprise to everyone in government? I don’t buy it. I also don’t buy that we need to do something NOW. Remember the Patriot Act? I also don’t buy the “credit contraction” explanation (excuse?).
It’s a house of cards. Let it fall.
September 30, 2008 12:22 PM
Grouchy Teacher said:
I agree,Max… my 403b and my wife’s 401k took no hits, we put it in safe places 6 mos ago, let the gamblers pay for their mistakes- remember “changing horses in mid-stream?” Rules don’t change because the big boys lose, or do they?
September 30, 2008 3:38 PM
Ellem said:
I agree w/ all that’s been said here — my husband and I are watching this from overseas, where we decided to move for work since it was impossible for us to buy a decent house based on our income (w/o shady deals/lying etc) –
recently we’ve been making plans to return to So. CA next summer, partly because it seemed the housing insanity had run its course and home prices were beginning to return to normal levels —
BUT now this . . .
and Ms. Allen made a good point, many people don’t understand what is going on and what this financial mess entails — in large part because some Americans simply don’t understand their own finances and consequences of their imprudent/foolish/naive financial choices –
however, many Americans DO understand their finances, and make level-headed, thoughtful decisions — and i’m afraid those of us in this category will be the steamrollered by the rest: the crooks and the incompetent.
I currently live/work in a country w/ quite low taxes, my employer matches my contribution to the pension plan and pays half my national health insurance premiums every month . . . it’s been a bit unreal watching this whole mess unfold in the US from afar. . . elected officials are elected to SERVE us, but while there is a lot of serving going on it seems to be more towards “self’ from what I can see . .
September 30, 2008 9:49 PM
Cindy Allen said:
Ellem, I want to move to your country!
October 1, 2008 2:43 PM
The Bailout Has to Pass, And It Will | Redfin Orange County Sweet Digs said:
[...] been reading and watching everything I can pertaining to the big bailout. Like a lot of people, I have mixed feelings about it: I hate the idea of rescuing everyone on Wall Street, but I don’t want to lose my job and my [...]
October 2, 2008 8:22 AM