September 1, 2008

Villa Park Turns Big Brother… I Say “Good!”

door night Villa Park Turns Big Brother... I Say Good!

An editorial article in the OC Register this Sunday caught my eye (“Villa Park is watching“).  It was a commentary on Villa Park’s new regulations on soliciting. Per the article, in July, the City passed an anti-soliciting ordinance that makes “it illegal to drop flyers off at people’s front doors or solicit anything before 10 a.m. or after 7 p.m., and it requires that those who distribute flyers pay $100 for a permit.” Also, “Anyone who distributes such materials or solicits business must avoid homes on the city’s ‘do not solicit’ registry.”

Councilwoman Deborah Pauly, a public supporter of the new regulation, claims that it’s to help keep “burglars and other evlidoers” out of the city.  What’s funny, is that Pauly was recenlty investigated for posting her political signs on properties (and of those who didn’t even support her).   So, what?  Keep those thugs out, but put my signs and political PR in your yards… great message from one of the Villa Park’s leaders.  There’s also been a movement to recall Pauly from office, but has not been successful.

While the OC Register’s editor seems to be up in arms about this new regulation: “We didn’t know it was the role of the government to ‘get a handle’ on who is ‘supposed’ to be there. It’s pretty creepy for a city to want to register and monitor visitors. It’s another reminder of how local officials are eager to tax, regulate and monitor our lives – all for our own good, of course.”  To this, I say, have you ever been home alone and two large men come knocking on your door at 9 p.m. trying to sell you candy bars for whatever cause?  While, of course, they could have been legitimate and really trying to help their after school program (or whatever it was), it was still a little scary.  I’ve never wished my husband was home and that we had a bigger dog more.  And, haven’t you heard of these strings of break-in’s recently targeting elderly woman?  Someone posing as a solicitor is a perfect way for someone to gauge a house for a break-in.

If I lived in Villa Park, would I sign up on this “do not solicit” list?  You bet!  Do I feel bad for the Girl Scouts and other non-profits (who are supposed to be exempt, but there doesn’t seem to be any protection in the regulation)? Eh, kind of.  Do I think it’s a little strict and a little bit too much big brother? Sure.  However, in this case, I would be willing to sacrifice a little personal freedom for additional protection.  Besides, why the heck do you really need to be coming to my house 7 p.m. or leaving me your business cards on my doorstep?  If I need a tree trimmer, I’ll ask my neighbors for a reference… or, heaven forbid, I’d look in the yellow pages.


  • Dominic... you said it! All it takes is one or two rude people to ruin it for all. I wish HOA regulations could a common courtesy regulation where if you're rude three times, you're out! Ha, yeah right, wishful thinking.

  • Dominic

    common sense?...who would have thought?!

    Julie, You are 100% right... but you got to wonder what goes through other peoples heads. The lack of common sense in a few people is part of what has provoked me to look for a home and hopefully move out of my condo. When you live so close to so many people you can have many great neighbors but it only takes one or two with a lack of consideration for others to spoil the environment for many others.

  • You know many of our laws and regulations wouldn't be necessary if people still had common courtesy and common sense. Don't call or knock on a door after 9pm (my mother taught me the same), control your barking dog, drive like a normal human being, etc., etc.

  • ellem

    Wow, it does sound a "teeny" bit Big Brother-ish, but like you, I could totally live with it, and in fact it would be a welcome idea in many parts of So. CA. When we lived in Long Beach (in a high-rise apartment on Ocean Blvd) we had some fellows come by around 9pm soliciting for magazines -- how they entered our building, we don't know - but a quick peek out the peephole and we ignored the doorbell/knocking, and eventually they moved on other doors.

    Still, that was a bit worrisome - it frightened us perhaps more than normal, since we lived in a controlled-access building -- but what if they had knocked at our house door, and they could see our lights on? Why do they think coming around at 9 pm was ok? I was always told by my mother that one doesn't call after 9pm, in order to respect other people's privacy -- and this ordinance in the end comes down to a matter of protecting privacy and the right not be hassled. It's one thing to have people soliciting at the entrance of Target or whatever, and a totally different matter when strangers knock late in the evening.

blog comments powered by Disqus
close