September 4, 2008

When SFR’s are Converted to Multiplexes: Should I be Upset?

9th ave multiplex edited 1 When SFRs are Converted to Multiplexes: Should I be Upset? It all started kind of gradually. First I noticed one house on a corner half a block from my house (pictured below) that had been vacant for months. Then contractors and builders started coming over a period of time: they redid a staircase here and converted a basement there.  When they were finished, I realized what had once stood as a single family home had become a multifamily unit. The I saw another house on the opposite end of the street undergo this transformation (pictured right). Then another. And now one more. There are at least four homes in a 2-block radius from my bungalow that have been converted from single family residences into duplexes or from duplexes into multiplexes. When the first one went up I didn’t think much of it. Even after the renovation it remained vacant for months and I assumed they were having a hard time renting it. Then several months ago a bevy of tenants moved in (it is a 3-unit building now). As I watched the three other buildings steadily being converted while the housing market took the mother-of-all-belly-flops, I began to grow more and more anxious: would these new aparment buildings cause my first house to drop its value even further? Would my home become difficult to sell someday due to all the rentals surrounding it? Will the owners manage the properties well? It also made me a little angry: what right does whoever is developing these units have to do so in a neighborhood that’s struggling to keep its value above water anyway? After all, chances are they’re not living here. I imagined that they were somewhere far away, like Dublin. Or San Jose. Then again, I could be wrong. Maybe property values won’t drop (at least, not due to these new units). On the bright side, the units are brand new and look relatively tasteful (though gargantuan) from the outside.  As long as their landlords keep them up, I suppose they could add to our neighborhood and not take away from it the way a vacant, blighted house can.  But ideally I’d like to see the blighted SFR’s become renovated and then sold (affordably) as SFR’s. (And likewise, if it’s a blighted duplex, renovate and remain a duplex, not become a megaplex). Should I dream on? Let me know your thoughts.

12th ave When SFRs are Converted to Multiplexes: Should I be Upset?


  • Alison
    Thanks for your comments everyone!

    Hi Jackie: how do we fight off the encroachment? Is this something we can take to city hall? I thought that we didn't have any say as long as they were getting all their permits legally, etc.

    Hi David: that's interesting about Chicago...but, we are in a very different area. And yeah.. they are apartments, not condos. Grr...

    Hi Red: uggghhhh... that's what I thought. So all these apartment conversions are yet ANOTHER piece of the fall-out from the housing meltdown: folks who bought SFRs at high prices are foreclosing, selling to developers/landlords who then, to turn a profit since they can't flip anymore, are turning the little ol' sfr's into megaplexes...then they get to rent them out to desperate former homeowners and/or other renters whose rents have gone up due to the surge of folks needing rental housing now!

    And I thought I was depressed when our house value went down...now with all these apartment complexes going up I feel even more disempowered. Sigh..
  • Red
    Conversion of a SFH to multi-unit rentals is not good for the neighborhood or your home value; since the home was not designed for that human density, normally the parking, noise and traffic issues have not been handled well and there is a negative impact on the neighbors. Low end renters tend to move frequently and not care for the property, and that affects perception of the neighborhood.
    I believe well designed multi-unit housing can be a real asset to the community, but the hodge-podge conversions are not it.
  • David
    The reaction (both on a residential and market level) here is interesting, compared to Chicago. Where I lived in Chicago, if a condo building/duplex/triplex went up, your SFR property value likely went up because in theory your house could sell, get re-zoned (for a ~$5000 bribe, er fee, to your alderman) and converted to a multi-unit where the units would presumably sell for more in toto than your SFR. Ergo, your land value would go up. It seems here (and most parts of California) if there are more multi-units in your 'hood, your 'hood is valued lower.

    I suppose the difference is that this is an apartment/rental now?
  • Jackie Aldridge
    That is an ugly multiplex. Poor quality of construction. Minimal parking . No upkeep on the landscaping. So, slumlords are moving in. You can try getting your neighbors together to fight off the encroachment. If your neighbors won't become active...
blog comments powered by Disqus
close